Garnet/White
Albert Peterson
Evan Vandenbrul / Ben Mascioli
Rose Alvarez
Valentina Giribaldi / Rylee Hall
Kim MacAfee
Meghan Arters / Madi Burford
Conrad Birdie
Mike Jones / Ben Daisy
Harry MacAfee
Hayden Brown / Josh Szkotak
Doris MacAfee
Kelly McGarrey / Hannah Van Rossum
Randolph MacAfee
AJ Lipiarski / Jack Cervino
Mae Peterson
Cecelia Mitcheli / Megan McGarrey
Hugo Peabody
Mason Miller / Ben Murphy
Ursula Merkle
Cara Greco / Jasmine Williams
Mayor
Mark Simunov / Tom Jeffers
Mayor's Wife
Lauren Devine / Rachel Elison
Gloria Rasputin
Ava Larue / Lainie Beauchemin
Harvey Johnson
Matt Hwang / Nick Cervino
Maude
Patrick Stoyer / Matt Hwang
Sad Girls
Kiera Adams and Lauren Bagley / Ally Dunn and Alexis Canzanese
Mrs. Merkle
Maria Simeone / Paige Caldwell
Helen
Camille Bautista / Alicia Bartosik
Nancy
Kiera Adams / Maddie Diskin
Margie
Mary Kate Sweeney / Vanessa Kenna
Deborah Sue
Lauren Bagley / Ally Dunn
Charles F. Maude
Pat Stoyer/ Matt Hwang
Phyllis
Tori Travetti/ Madie O'Day
Traveler
Natalie Boettger
Reporters
Josh Heins, Jessica Clowsely and Julia Kinnee / Charity Sassi and Kate Santangelo
Male Featured Dancers
Zach Smith, David Anderson, Tommy Kelly, Roy Maxfield, Joshua Sherman, Drake Schultz