(in order of appearance)
Molly (orphan)
Monica Hodgson (Spotlight), Krista Johnson (Curtain)
Pepper (orphan)
Jessica Bost (Curtain), Skye Palacios (Spotlight)
Duffy (orphan)
Mauriella Adolphus (Curtain), Abigayl Salapka (Spotlight)
July (orphan)
Chloe Reed (Curtain), Lily Schiavino (Spotlight)
Tessie (orphan)
Dahlia Davis (Spotlight), Emilia Kozak (Curtain)
Annie
Hannah Motin (Spotlight), Christina Siacavelas (Curtain)
Kate (orphan)
Lia Lehmkuhl (Curtain), Lucy Lloyd (Spotlight)
Miss Hannigan
Jenna Barnes (Curtain), Savannah Posen (Spotlight)*
Bundles McCloskey (laundry man)
Nico Fama (Curtain), Ryder Redondo (Spotlight)
Apple Seller
Rylee Severino (Curtain), Sarah Sullivan (Spotlight)
Dogcatcher
Collin Bitalla (Curtain), Timothy Sullivan (Spotlight)
Officer Ward (policeman)
Drew Fontana (Spotlight), Matthew Reed (Curtain)*
Grace Farrell
Mia Masarik (Curtain)*, Mia Williams (Spotlight)
Drake (butler)
Daniel Bergondo (Curtain), Luca Scalora (Spotlight)
Cecille (maid)
Hannah Jolly (Curtain), Penelope Vignuolo (Spotlight)
Mrs. Greer (housekeeper)
Lauren Gouveia (Spotlight), Sage Woods (Curtain)
Annette (maid)
Emily Bost (Curtain), Kaitlyn Wilberforce (Spotlight)
Mrs. Pugh (cook)
Rylee Severino (Curtain), Sarah Sullivan (Spotlight)
