Act I
The Lord is My Shepherd
Choir
Once Upon a Morning
Silas, Godfrey, Sarah, Molly
You Didn't Hear it From Me
Ensemble
Most Important Fellow
Ensemble
Day by Day/Now and Ever After
Godfrey, Molly
Mrs. Winthrop Has the Cure
Mrs. Winthrop, Mr. Waite
Now and Ever After - Reprise
Molly, Young Eppie
Fate Deals the Cards
Dunstan
Find the River
Silas, Sarah
If Only
Silas, Godfrey, Sarah, Molly, Nancy
Sing Out, Ye Merry Men
Ensemble
Lullaby
Young Aaron, Young Eppie, Silas, Sarah
In the Glow of the Fire
Silas, Sarah, Young Eppie
The Spinning Mule
Ensemble
A Girl I Used to Know
Godfrey
Lullaby - Reprise
Silas, Godfrey, Sarah, Nancy
Act II
Correspondence
Godfrey, Nancy
North Star
Godfrey, Nancy
It Takes a Village
Ensemble
The Stranger
Godfrey, Silas, Young Eppie, Older Eppie
In My Mind
Silas, Older Eppie, Godfrey
The Way You Make Me Feel
Older Aaron, Older Eppie
Right/Moonless Night - Reprise
Godfrey, Silas, Sarah
You'll Never Know
Sarah, Silas, Nancy, Godfrey
I Believe - Reprise
Ensemble
